I write this as someone who has considered himself as an
activist since I was 16 – just over 50 years ago. I could list all of the “actions” that I’ve
been part of as my bona fides, but that seems tiresome to do. You’ll have to accept my statement at face
value – as a statement that at least I see as a fact that informs what I write
here.
I like to see the young folks from around the country
engaged in active response to the problems of gun violence. They are passionate, focused, and gaining
skills in how to make their message have impact. At the moment, they are getting lots of
attention, so their voices are being heard in places and by people who have
ignored the problems generated by gun violence.
Good for them!
But I see all the markings of the end of this movement
before the movement even gets underway. Energy,
passion, and current focus just aren’t enough to maintain the momentum that
will lead to intended changes. Activists
need to develop the “legs” they need to carry their ideas on the long march to
change. What do I mean by “legs”? Legs are the coalitions that bring together
multiple constituencies for sustained action around a multi-pronged plan that
includes legislative, social, and economic changes. Legs are what it takes to merge ideas into a
coherent statement of purpose. Legs
means that there are activists who will make this work their life’s mission and
commit multiple years to creating change.
Legs mean that a movement has to work toward goals while effectively
dealing with the inevitable and fatiguing infighting and divergence of opinion
that mark the leaders of any action group.
If you look at any social movement that has long-term impact, it takes
all of that.
These barriers to success aren’t an outcome of right- or
left-leaning politics. Look at the
alt-right movement that seemed to coalesce under the banner of the president in
the last election. It’s falling apart at
every level because of these issues as national figures like Steve Bannon start
jockeying for power. Or smaller figures
get wrapped up in the nexus of internecine wars and the demands of their
personal lives. It’s no different on the
left of the political spectrum. You
don’t have to look too far back in the left’s history to recall the “Occupy”
movement that was going to change the way that the nation looked at its
economic structure. After months of
huddling in tents of the cold streets of New York and elsewhere, that effort
seems to have dissolved into factions and slogans that can still be heard at
rallies.
What will keep this current youth movement from gaining
legs? First, and most importantly, we
can’t expect that high school students will give up their futures and fight for
this cause for the time it will take to address all of the federal and state
laws required to make changes. The NRA
and the legislators the NRA has bought know this. These young people will graduate from high
school and they will go out and get jobs, or enter training programs or attend
college. That’s what they should
do. They can be advocates in those
roles, but being leaders in a movement that generates national change isn’t a
part-time job. They are fighting against
one of the best financed machines in the history of the nation.
And as much as I’d like to share the David-and-Goliath
idealism that beliefs can conquer all, that’s just not how things work. We got to this point in our history because
gun manufacturers in the past 30 years have used the NRA as a tool to generate
public opinion and policies that run contrary to what had been opinion and
policy for almost 200 years prior. The gun
lobby/NRA’s machine has the legs that millions of dollars have bought so that it
can create public campaigns and legislation, and shape public perception. Beating that machine will take more time and
energy than enthusiastic young people can provide in the short time they have
to keep the nation’s attention.
I keep seeing these new activists being compared to the
movements in the 1960s that brought about such change in that decade and the
decades following. The myth is that era’s
change was brought about by youth marching in the streets and organizing for
change. Yes, that was at times the
visible component. But behind the peace
movement was decades of organizing history and knowledge that groups like the
American Friends Service Committee and the support of religious leaders like
the Berigan brothers; and behind the civil rights marches were the Black
churches and organizing structures like that of the NAACP and the Southern
Christian Leadership Council. These
groups began well before the 1960s, and they had the staying power to hold the
fight after marchers’ initial enthusiasms waned and during the moments when no
spotlight was being held on their issues.
Today’s activists would do well to learn from those experiences instead
of hearing the misguided mythology that they’ll be adequate in and of
themselves. For their efforts to impact
their cause of gun violence, it seems they would benefit from connecting to the
groups and organizations that are already engaged in the work.
I’m actually heartened by seeing these young folks doing
this work. Good for them for caring
about their world enough to demand that it change. As they move on with their lives, my
experiences tell me that their current activism will shape how they interact
with the world, and that’s a good thing.
We need more actively engaged citizens who demand that our government
and our society offer safety, justice, and opportunity to all. So I believe that this movement will have
lots of impact in the long term as we encourage more young people to be engaged
in the society.
But for now, let’s find ways to leverage their work into the
efforts that have longstanding viability.
Let’s help them to see their work as part of a continuum of other work
that precedes them and will last beyond them.
Let’s help them to see the ways in which they can channel their passion
to work with other people and organizations that can help them learn and can
help their work persist.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Enter your comments below. Comments are moderated by the blog author and will be available after review. Please note that if you have cookies; blocked, you won't be able to post.